A shopper chooses a product, then reaches a row of suggestions. One looks like an alternative. Another looks like something they need to use the first item. The page calls both “You may also like.”
Give each recommendation a clear reason to be there. For a Scottsdale shop using Shopify, that means separating another choice from an extra purchase and checking the path into the cart.
Start with a few important product pages. You do not need to fill every available recommendation slot to make those pages more useful.
Decide what the suggestion helps someone do
Open a product page and write down the question the recommendations should answer. Is the customer still comparing choices, or have they found the main item and need something to use with it?
Shopify distinguishes related products, which can offer similar alternatives, from complementary products bought alongside the main item. Search & Discovery lets you choose recommendations for a product. Read Shopify’s recommendation guidance.
Imagine a Scottsdale kitchen shop selling a pour-over coffee dripper. A different dripper could be an alternative. Suitable paper filters could be an add-on. A photo showing both does not explain whether the filters come in the box.
A different dripper to compare.
Explains an alternative.Suitable filters sold separately.
Explains an add-on.Use headings that match the actual choices. “Other drippers” and “Filters sold separately” tell different stories. Keep those descriptions accurate for the specific items beneath them.
If you sell a packaged set instead, use our product-bundle guide. A recommendation beside a product is not a written list of what that purchase contains.
Verify the match before writing the label
Have someone who knows the merchandise review each proposed pairing. Use the exact product and option, not a general category name.
For the imagined kitchen shop, check the filter shape and size against the dripper’s product information or supplier instructions. A similar package photograph is not enough to establish a fit.
Write down the evidence behind any compatibility wording. If a recommendation works with only some options, put that condition where customers make the choice. Avoid a broad “works with this” label above a product with several different versions.
- Identify
- The exact main product and selected option.
- Verify
- The supplier guidance or product specification that supports the pairing.
- Explain
- Any fit condition and whether the extra is sold separately.
Also check what the main purchase already includes. Recommending another of the same item might be useful as a spare, but it should not imply that an included part must be purchased separately.
Keep necessary accessories in the main product explanation. A customer should not have to discover an essential requirement by scrolling through optional suggestions.
Our product-choice guide covers keeping the selected option clear. Carry that same clarity into recommended products.
Check the saved choices and the live template
Ask your maintainer which product template and recommendation settings control the page. Save the page address and a note of the recommendation group you are changing.
Shopify’s related-products section can display automatically generated or manually selected products. The theme determines its heading and layout. Review the related-products section documentation.
After changing a selection, open the public page. Check the names, prices, images and destination links. Repeat this on another product using the same template if the layout or heading was changed.

Automatic related suggestions can change, and the app’s preview can differ from the storefront. Shopify allows manual related selections on their own or alongside generated suggestions. See its customization options.
Review every group that appears on the page. A carefully chosen add-on row does not establish that a separate automatic row contains suitable alternatives.
Investigate missing recommendations in context
If a chosen item is absent, check its eligibility before repeatedly adding it again. Record the main product, the missing item and whether the cart was empty during the test.
Shopify requires recommended products to be active, published to the Online Store, priced above zero, not gift cards and not already in the cart. Complementary items need positive stock; related items can qualify at zero stock when continued selling is enabled. Check the current recommendation requirements.
Have your maintainer review the complete requirements and the actual theme. Do not change stock settings merely to force a suggestion to appear.
Test with an empty cart, then with the suggested item already added. Record the difference. If the recommendation area becomes empty, check that its heading and surrounding spacing still make sense.
Our sold-out product guide covers the wider availability message. Keep that message consistent with the product page reached from a recommendation.
Follow the suggestion into the cart
On a phone, start at the main product and follow a recommended item. Read its full details, choose the intended option and add it to the cart. Then check the saved item, option, quantity and price.
If your theme offers a quick-add control, test that route separately. Confirm that any necessary option choice is visible before the item is added. Do not assume the shortcut behaves like the full product page.
Use the keyboard as well. Reach each recommendation link and control, check visible focus, and make sure any option panel can be closed without losing your place.
For the kitchen-shop example, the cart should make the dripper and separately purchased filters recognizable as distinct items. Remove the filters and confirm that the remaining purchase still reads clearly.
Repeat the important steps with a longer product name and an item with several options. Check the actual text, not just whether the cards align neatly.
Keep a reason and an owner for each pairing
Record why a manual recommendation exists and who checks it when products change. Revisit the pairing when a supplier changes a specification, an option is retired or the main product’s included contents change.
Search & Discovery provides recommendation click and purchase reports, plus a report for recommendations with low engagement. See Shopify’s report definitions.
Use those reports to choose pages worth investigating. A low click rate alone does not explain whether the item was unsuitable, the label was unclear or the customer simply did not need it.
Combine the report with the actual page, product questions and your team’s knowledge of the stock. Record changes before comparing later activity. Avoid attributing a sales change to one rearranged row without supporting evidence.
Choose one recommendation group on your Scottsdale business website. Our e-commerce service can help connect the suggestion, product details and cart. Show Brandon the shopping step you want to improve.
